Diagonal elements

Содержание черновиков
It is really not systematized preliminary materials about this topic
Далее это просто «свалка» не систематизированных заметок заметок

STEP 3.3. Write the formulation of a physical contradiction at the macro level:
Theory
Original text of Altshuller
http://www.altshuller.ru/triz/ariz85v-3.asp
PC “of existence”
STEP 3.3. Write the formulation of the physical contradiction at the macro-level:
operational zone
during the operational time
should be (indicate physical macro-state, for example, “be hot”),
in order to perform the action (indicate one of the conflicting actions),
and should not be (indicate the opposite physical macro-state, for example, “be cool”),
in order to perform the action (name another conflicting action or requirement).
Notes
25. A physical contradiction (PC) is understood as contradictory requirements to the physical state of the opertional zone.
26. If the compiling of an exhaustive formulation of PC causes difficulties, one can compile a short formulation:
component (or part of a component in the operational zone)
should be…, in order to… (indicate),
and should not be, in order to (indicate).
PC – “as related to the parameter”

1.1. ( вес подвижного объекта) не проблема: дирижабль, подводная лодка, автомобиль, самолёт, очки…
2.2 ( вес неподвижного объекта), тоже не проблема: стол , стул, здание, дом, палатка, сваи для фундаментов на вечной мерзлоте, гараж…
15.15 (время действия подвижного объекта) – как это понять? Например эффективность ? Или долговечность ? Тогда будут корректными примеры: копьё – пуля или тетива лука и пороховой заряд или идея рекуперации электрической энергии в гибридных автомобилях, увеличение дальности пробега
16.16 (время действия неподвижного объекта) как это можно понять ? Неподвижного значит « не перемещаемого, не мобильного? Долговечность изделия ? Скорость производительность ? Время изготовления монет, сначала литьё – потом штамповка – потом крипто валюты «биткоин»

Physical Contradiction
Special case according to
Trimming approach
Some parameter
Theory

Theory

Theory

Theory

TESE and PC
We can solve PC with 40 principles and with TESE also.
Theory

Theory

Remark for testing:
Without opposing the definitions offered by the author of TRIZ, Physical contradiction implied contradictory requirements to the physical state of operation zone.
The following practical definition could be offered. PC, (like EC) is one of the possible forms (methods) of thinking about the disadvantage of ES, the efficiency of which is provided for through:
A) Identification of an important parameter, which has to be changed, in order to improve ES as a marketable goods (“PC with regard to parameter”). Parameter should be both Big and Small. This is a manifestation of Hegel’s dialectics “unity and conflict of two opposed categories” and the principles of laws of preservation in physics).
B) To implant in the subconscious the doubt to use one of the components of this engineering system (ES) in general (“PC of existence” or 1 and О _ there should be a certain element in ES and there should’t be such element in ES. This format is directly associated with the ideas of decreasing the number of components in ES by transfer of function from one part of the system to another part of the system – “trimming”.
In its turn, the ideas of trimming are associated with one of the main heuristics of classical TRIZ, one of the forms of IFR – “there is no engineering system, while the function is performed”. There is an aphorism “The best component of the tank is the one, which is missing – it cannot be broken”.
The conclusion is as follows – according to the definitions of GSA concerning PC, the user of the tools of classical TRIZ should be able to find with the engineering system both “PC with regard to parameter” and “PC of existence”, since these habits define this or that level of creativity of the tested person as capacities for identification of a full or not very full set of disadvantages of analyzed and studied object. These considerations enable to develop a procedure for measuring creativity by comparing the results of the test yielded by the tested person with a reference answer. That is a “Creativity coefficient according to TRIZ”
What is the way Technology 1 is associated with the methodological tradition of ARIZ 85 В “from identified EC to formulation of PC”.
There is some interesting interpretation of IFR model. According to modern vision IFR can be applicable with idea of TRIMMING and PC, because according to definition of G. Altsuller there is two types of physical contradictions: 1) parameter must be bigg and small and 2) some object mist be exist and not exist ( 1 or 0)
Theory

PRIMITIVE STRUCTURE
MICRO LEVEL
exist
Not exist
1
0
Trimming direction
Theory

=
PC- exist/not exist
(1/ 0) and “trimming” (delegation of function)
(some parameter)
Theory

Another examples PC 1/0 ( pump for wheel)
Knife for repairing

PC- exist/not exist (1/ 0) and IFR
Theory

Theory
Helper for search “X element”
Legend
N
Principles
{1 ---- 40}

1. Weight of moveable object
2. Weight of immobile object
3. Length of moveable object
4. Length of immobile object
5. Area of moveable object
6. Area of immobile object
7. Volume of moveable object
8. Volume of immobile object
9. Speed
10. Force
11. Tension, pressure
12. Shape
13. Stability of object composition
14. Strength
15. Action time of moveable object
16. Action time of immobile object
17. Temperature
18. Light
19. Energy consumption by the moveable object
20. Energy consumption by immobile object
21. Power
22. Energy losses
23. Substance losses
24. Information losses
25. Time losses
26. Amount of substance
27. Reliability
28. Measuring accuracy
29. Manufacturing accuracy
30. Harmful factors acting upon the object
31. Harmful factors of the object proper
32.Convenience of manufacturing
33. Convenience of operation
34. Convenience of repair
35. Adaptation, universality
36. Complexity of device
37. Complexity of control and measuring
38. Degree of automation
39. Efficiency
Necessary create the inspection between 39 parameters from Altsuller’s matrix and 30 popular disadvantages. Several parameters from list 39 is clear, several parameters not clear…
After creation of helper, connector between 39 and 30, we can create database for PC in diagonal elements for Altsuller’s matrix.

Disadvantages
as fundament
of thinking
Engineering contradiction 1
and reasoning via principles
Physical contradiction N
And reasoning via TESE
Physical contradiction N
And reasoning via IFR
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
It is picture of hormone. I use it for explanation evolution of goods: D ( reason) → creations of new products

«crate of information»
evolution
of need
Professional collection
By Y.Danilovsky
[e-mail]
http://www.triz-solver.com/index.php/teoriya-nedostatkov/235-a-martix-for-training

Crisis in evolution of 연필
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collet
1560
2012
1560,an Italian couple named Simonio and Lyndiana Bernacotti
Пластик
use plastic
бумага
http://ko.wikipedia.org/wiki/연필
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bleistift
452
9
10
11
12
Копировальный
Карандаш
«химический»
13
14
15
paper
Pencil for wood

АЭРОГРАФИЯ
AEROGRAPHY
(AEROSOL)
LASER SHOW

Use LED and mimicry for sand’s watch